Calling BS on BO


Update2: Uncle Jimbo weighs in (via h/a)

The ABC report drops it from heinous to just ignorant. My main beef is that such a silly sounding story made it to the debate as Obama’s main point about the military. It was slanted and not an accurate portrayal, thus emphasizing his weakness for the CinC role.

Update: Jake Tapper says the story “Checks out

From last night’s debate in Austin:

BHO:

“I heard from a Army captain, who was the head of a rifle platoon, supposed to have 39 men in a rifle platoon. Ended up being sent to Afghanistan with 24, because 15 of those soldiers had been sent to Iraq. And as a consequence, they didn’t have enough ammunition; they didn’t have enough humvees.

Linkfest Haven, the Blogger's OasisThey were actually capturing Taliban weapons because it was easier to get Taliban weapons than it was for them to get properly equipped by our current commander in chief. Now that’s a consequence of bad judgment, and you know, the question is on the critical issues that we face right now who’s going to show the judgment to lead.”

This doesn’t pass the smell test with me on several levels.

First, if there were any truth to this, the media would not have hesitated to use it to bash George Bush. It would have been all over the news.

Second, some of my military readers might want to weigh in here, but, how common is it for an Army Captain to be a Platoon leader? Captains don’t lead platoons, they lead Companies.

Third, how does a under-equipped, under-supplied, half-strength platoon capture munitions, weapons and supplies from the enemy? You mean the Taliban is just handing them over?

BHO is not only revealing himself to be a plagiarist and a demagogue, but a liar as well.

UPDATE: more at NRO

the Obama military anecdote was absolute rubbish on so many levels. First, on his understanding of the military: Captains don’t command platoons, Second, we don’t split platoons between Iraq and Afghanistan, not even companies, battalions, or brigades. Sometimes divisions but by then you’re talking about a 12-15,000 man organization so splits make sense. Done it since WWI at that level and even below. The idea that one of the lowest level organizations in the army (a 40 person platoon) is split between a war with 40,000 troops in it and another war with 120,000 is beyond silly. If Clinton knew better herself, she could have slammed him for knowing nothing about the military, but she’s not in much better shape there herself.

As for the substance, absolute crap. Lots of things happen in a complex theater like Afghanistan but I don’t know anybody who has heard anything even close to that story in 6.5 years military involvement there.

++++

This is the World Famous Friday Open Thread. A Free Speech Zone.

Please post your comments, links, threads, videos, questions, shoutouts, track-backs, and other items of interest.

WFFOT: Be the thread.


Trackposted to Outside the Beltway, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Right Truth, Leaning Straight Up, Big Dog’s Weblog, Cao’s Blog, Conservative Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Woman Honor Thyself, Pirate’s Cove, The Pink Flamingo, Celebrity Smack, Wolf Pangloss, , The Yankee Sailor, and Gone Hollywood, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

37 Responses

  1. This is the same military wizard that made this comment:

    “I think what is irresponsible and naive is to have authorized a war without asking how we were going to get out — and you know I think Senator Clinton hasn’t fully answered that issue.

    Source.
    For B-Ho’s edification, if he knew anything at all about the military, the way you get out of a war is called VICTORY!

  2. Turkey launches ground ops in Iraq
    Link

  3. Hunh.
    Even my Kurdish friends who are not associated with the PKK are sympathetic with them. Turkey is taking advantage of the IA while they are deeply involved with restoring security to the rest of Iraq. The area that the PKK operates in is very remote, but the sovereignty issue is creating unnecessary tension. If the Kurdish authorities would do more to control the PKK this wouldn’t happen, but they won’t. The animosity with Turkey, and the way they have treated Kurds since the Ottoman Empire collapsed, is enormous.

  4. Well, I’m sure Zerobama has some hope he can share with the Kurds

  5. He’s the greatest hope for all of mankind, didn’t you get the memo?
    /just in case…sarc

  6. I’m from Mississippi. I got the memo, but I can’t read it.
    /just waiting for that pantsload of change to fix everything wrong in the universe

  7. I think that pantsload of B-HO’s is already present.

  8. if there were any truth to this, the media would not have hesitated to use it to bash George Bush…no doubt about that Nukester!..ty for the link! 🙂

  9. From the comment section at Flopping Aces.

    What a crock of outright lies and BS!!!! Platoons are not split up along theater level lines. A Platoon is the smallest tactical element commonly employed. Normal Squads, which make up Platoons, do not go out alone unless covered by something big (Tank/Infantry squad teams for example).

    Units are not halved for combat!! Units in Afghanistan were not used in Iraq and the two events occurred almost a year apart!! 10th Mountain went into Afghanistan fully manned. 10th Mountain was not used in Iraq. Also, all units have organic vehicles. Divisions are not stripped of vehicles for another theater operation. We have APS fleets to cover this (pre-deployed assets in Kuwait)!!! Obama should know about this as funding for the APS fleets are in the appropriations bills.

    So on this aspect: FLAT OUT LIE by Obama!!!!!!

    Now, as for Obama’s military skills, exactly WHAT captain leads a platoon?????? 2LTs lead platoons with a few 1LTs who might lead one as the senior platoon leader in a company, COMMANDED by a captain. Maybe this was a captain who lead a platoon years ago, however, Obama’s lack of knowledge betrays him. Even if Obama is not slandering/making up a story by the officer, it will be the first anyone I know of has heard about this lack of equipment and ammo issue.

    Now as for weapons. No kidding we use the enemy’s when we can. The same is true for the initial invasion of Iraq. Ammunition is always a sought commodity, but there was no shortage of transports getting it to Afghanistan. HOWEVER, in the midst of a fire fight, ammo runs low and many Soldiers/Marines know how to use the AK series (AKM/AK-74 and SVD). Since a majority of US Military Members are gun owners/shooters and many are NRA members, we tend to learn all we can about weapons and teach those who are not hunters/shooters in our ranks. A light infantry unit can only carry so much ammo on extended missions. Air resupply is not always available while in combat (helicopters draw enemy fire for some reason) and ground resupply is not always able to get up the goat trails that comprise Afghanistan.

    However, I know a captain who commanded in 10th Mountain in Afghanistan during the most intense fighting there and he NEVER had problems with lack of men, equipment, or ammo. But then, I am an Army officer who, like a VAST, near total majority of us, supports the war so my opinion is unwanted by the left.

    The more Obama speaks, the more he digs holes.
    February 21st, 2008 at 9:50 pm

    Link

  10. “But then, I am an Army officer who, like a VAST, near total majority of us, supports the war so my opinion is unwanted by the left.”

    If a “vast majority of us” supports the war then how come Ron Paul and Barack Obama received more campaign contributions from the military than any other candidate? I’m pretty sure that they are both all for pulling out of Iraq as soon as possible. Don’t believe what one guy from the Army says. The numbers and statistics speak the truth.

    http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=3601542&page=1

  11. Not the point clyde. But just to make you happy, read what others have said.
    Pentagon Refutes Obama

  12. I guess we’ll see how many of the military votes the dems try to suppress this election cycle. If it is as you say, then we will see a record turnout.

  13. never underestimate the power of a good “rollicking”

  14. Amazing story….

  15. Good find on that Flopping Aces comment, Robert D.
    So Clyde says we should believe an ABC story, but not the word of an actual Army officer? Oh, man…LOL!

  16. Typical Kool Aid drinker…..

  17. Daaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnnngggggggggggg!
    Dude just won a new Cadillac XLR convertible on his Price Is Right showcase, and since he won his bid by less than one thousand dollars, he won both showcases, and one million dollars.
    /dang

  18. So Robert D, did that quake in Nev. get felt where you are?

  19. Didn’t feel a thing. They say they felt it in Socal, But that’s a crock of, well, you know…

  20. […] Dog’s Weblog, Cao’s Blog, Conservative Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Nuke Gingrich, Woman Honor Thyself, Pirate’s Cove, Celebrity Smack, The Pink Flamingo, Wolf Pangloss, Dumb […]

  21. […] to Nuke Gingrich, A Blog For All, 123beta, Right Truth, Pirate’s Cove, Celebrity Smack, The Pink Flamingo, […]

  22. […] Truth, Shadowscope, Oblogatory Anecdotes, Cao’s Blog, Conservative Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Nuke Gingrich, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The Pink Flamingo, Celebrity Smack, Wolf Pangloss, Dumb Ox […]

  23. Independent Conservative Talk Radio

    Mondays at 11pm eastern – The Halls of Valhalla http://www.blogtalkradio.com/hallsofvalhalla Tuesday Through Thursday 9pm eastern- http://www.uncooperativeradio.com/ The Uncooperative Radio show Friday’s 8pm Eastern – The Patriot’s Pub! http://www.pa

  24. […] to Outside the Beltway, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, The Virtuous Republic, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Nuke Gingrich, Right Truth, Shadowscope, Pirate’s Cove, The Pink Flamingo, Big Dog’s Weblog, […]

  25. A Different Kind of Diplomacy for Condi Rice in Gh

    Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, right, who is accompanying President Bush, not pictured, is embraced by Emmanuel Oti Boateng, a tribal leader, after being briefed on the USAID West Africa Trade Hub, Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2008, at the International…

  26. […] Oblogatory Anecdotes, Cao’s Blog, Conservative Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Pursuing Holiness, Nuke Gingrich, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, Pirate’s Cove, The Pink Flamingo, Dumb Ox Daily News, , […]

  27. New York Times Executive Editor Bill Keller Had Af

    Im sure everyone has heard about the Old Grey Ladys hit piece on John McCain. If you havent heard about it you havent been on the internet or turned on your television today. It certainly got Michelle Obamas lack of pride in her country off the …

  28. John McCain is a Supporter of Israel

    John McCain is a supporter of Israel. He has consistently been a supporter of Israel.

    WASHINGTON – A little while after the outbreak of the Second Lebanon War, a group of Israelis visited Senator John McCain in his office, armed with maps. Amo…

  29. Obama Exposes His Ignorance of the Military

    I cringed when I heard the clip of Obama trying to sound like he knew something about the military. I think that anyone who does know anything about the military was probably equally appalled or laughing.

  30. […] Cao’s Blog, Conservative Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Pursuing Holiness, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Nuke Gingrich, Woman Honor Thyself, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, Pirate’s Cove, The Pink Flamingo, […]

  31. ROFL. I started to tell SwampMan about Obama’s remarks; I didn’t get any further than “he said that a CPT that was a platoon leader” before SwampMan declared bullSHIT.

  32. […] Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Pursuing Holiness, Chuck’s Place, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Nuke Gingrich, Woman Honor Thyself, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, Pirate’s Cove, The Pink Flamingo, […]

  33. Military Defense Under Barack Obama in Under One M

    And people say that Barack Obama is never specific about what his plans are should he be elected President of the United States ::shudder::. He explains exactly what his plans are for our military defense systems in under one minute. He’s pretty spec…

  34. From Inside the McCain Campaign

    I have actually enjoyed reading the McCain Blogette. McCains daughter, Meghan McCain, does a great job with the blog. This is her latest vlog. Theres an explanation for the jumping. I hope youll go by and check out her blog. It gives an interestin…

  35. […] Calling BS on BO « nuke gingrich // Friday, February 22, 2008 at 10:19 […]

  36. Yea buthead and Lindsey Lohan is pregnant with Eugene Osei’s child. Eugene Osei is a some rich hollywood wierdo who parties his life away. we should be worried about who is going to take care of the child..

Comments are closed.

TIME NEVER DIES

Sercan Ondem

The Light

Inspire, Encourage and Empower

resultizedotcom.wordpress.com/

All about career, personal development, productivity & leadership

TIME NEVER DIES

Sercan Ondem

The Reset Blog

Start over, just don't stop

raulconde001

A topnotch WordPress.com site

My life as Atu's Blog

a small thougt for a big planet of daydreamer

Taffy Toffy's Blog

太妃糖的博客

tekehdddddddddddddddddddddddddddd.wordpress.com/

About life, the universe and everything

Drowning in depression.

Is'nt it great being a human!

%d bloggers like this: