Where For Art Thou, Severance?

An excellent piece in American Thinker, Obamacares Fatal Flaw(?), informs us of the potential demise of this enormous government power grab.

Virginia is asserting that certain portions (that is, the personal mandate) of ObamaCare are unconstitutional. If Virginia prevails, it leaves the question of what happens to the rest of the ObamaCare statute. This is where the concept of severance comes in. Normally, all comprehensive laws contain a boilerplate severance clause: it says that if any portion of the law is found to be unconstitutional, that portion is severed from the rest of the law — that is, the rest of the law stands.

But ObamaCare contains no severance clause. Virginia is asserting that if it prevails on its substantive claims, the whole law is unconstitutional. (If Virginia does not prevail, any one of the twenty-plus legal challenges have the same severance argument available.)

If a severance clause is normal boilerplate, why does not ObamaCare contain one? This is where Scott Brown’s election enters.

Read it all, it is most excellent.

I will not, and encourage all not too, consider this a victory until the black robes have performed all their rituals.

13 Responses

  1. Okay then, I’ll say “Yay.” without any exclamation points! : )

  2. now, ain’t that interesting.

  3. Heh. Guess passing it in order to read what was in it wasn’t the best strategy after all, Nancy.

  4. wordpress is iffy tonight.

  5. It might have possibilities if money don’t talk.

    I have been busy enough not to track down. Correct me if I am wrong. Isn’t Brown becoming a RINO.

  6. Hunh. I wouldn’t even call Crist a RINO. Just one of those opportunistic assholes with no actual values that will call themselves anything to get elected.

Comments are closed.


Sercan Ondem

The Light

Inspire, Encourage and Empower


All about career, personal development, productivity & leadership


Sercan Ondem

The Reset Blog

Start over, just don't stop


A topnotch WordPress.com site

My life as Atu's Blog

a small thougt for a big planet of daydreamer

Taffy Toffy's Blog



About life, the universe and everything

Drowning in depression.

Is'nt it great being a human!

%d bloggers like this: